Addressing criticalities in the INFOGEST static in vitro digestion protocol for oleogel analysis

Abstract

The interest on the digestive fate of oleogels, i.e., substitutes for solid fats rich in liquid oil, have pushed researchers to use the widely adopted INFOGEST protocol for static in vitro digestion. However, this protocol was originally designed to simulate the digestibility of conventional foods and to accommodate the large fraction of oil in oleogels, researchers have deliberately modified the INFOGEST protocol, inadvertently leading to results difficult to be compared. In this study, we highlighted possible problems that may arise during oleogel simulated digestion such as under- or overestimation of oleogel lipolysis. The effect of oleogel amount, oleogelator type and concentration, and shear applied during digestion on the rate and extent of oleogel digestion was studied. The release of fatty acids during the application of INFOGEST protocol was monitored using the pH-stat method and compared to those analyzed by HPLC-ELSD. Oleogels' structural information was obtained using brightfield, polarized, and fluorescence microscopy, and DSC. We determined that lipolysis of ethylcellulose oleogels follow the "interaction with enzymes and bile salts" pattern, whereas that of wax oleogels follow the "disintegration of oleogel and interaction with enzymes and bile salts". We also observed that the chemical composition of wax, crystal morphology, and crystal distribution do not alter the lipolysis of oil entrapped inside the wax crystals. We finally recommended a few minimal but fundamental modifications to the INFOGEST protocol to achieve more reliable results from the static in vitro digestion of oleogels and possibly other lipid-based systems.